« Unbroken | Main | Mad Women »

The Virgin and the Griffin


I want to be frank with you. I know the author of this book. She used to write a blog for Slow Travel A Journey of 1000 Miles... (you can find her out her new blog, Leaping Without a Net). That out of the way, I want to give you my honest assessment of The Virgin and the Griffin, maybe even too honest in an over-critical way to make up for our friendship.

The Virgin and the Griffin tells the story of Isabella, a young women of Perugia in the early 1500s, belonging to a family of weavers, during a time when women were not allowed to work (for commercial gain). The story is set against the backdrop of some potential upheaval between the noble families of the time and the Vatican (Perugia, as I learned, was under the control of the Pope). And this brings me to my first point.

The author's command of the history of Perugia Italy as well as its geography is amazing. She creates a vivid sense of place, so much so, that when I do finally get to visit Perugia, I will re-read this book in order to get a better idea of the places I want to see. Additionally, her knowledge of the textile industry at that time and the process through which the weavers work is also exemplary and presented in an interesting and easy to understand fashion.

But this leads me to a slight negative, there is so much history to impart that at times it felt as if the information became repetitive, repeating some of the back story (e.g., talking about the ruthlessness of the Baglioni or that they appeared at the top of the hierarchy of Perugia's nobles) in order to ensure the reader understood the context within which the characters lived. At the beginning, it slowed the story down a bit.

That said, once I was 30 - 40% in (again, Kindle reader here), I was hooked and did not want to put it down. The author develops her characters so well, and Isabella becomes so real that thoughts of their lives stayed with me well after the book ended. Again though this brings up three asides.

First, I doubt the author realizes this, but her main character has the same name as the main character of the Twilight series (yuck), which I had the unfortunate experience of reading (well, the first book), and every time someone spoke to "Bella" I had horrid flashbacks to Twilight and Edward Cullen - bleh.

Second, is in homage to another friend, Stephanie, I wanted more closure (Stephanie cannot stand a book without closure). I grew to really enjoy these characters (especially Letizia, who I wish we knew even more - perhaps a prequel?), and I wanted to know how the rest of their lives went. We're really only given a glimpse into maybe two years (sorry I don't have the book in front of me) of their lives and it wasn't enough.

Lastly, while I'm talking about characters, the story is told in the first person by Isabella though at times the author breaks and switches viewpoints to some of the other characters. I'm assuming (I know, bad to assume), that she does that to give us some insight into their thoughts/emotions but I think she's a strong enough writer that she didn't need to do this. I think Isabella's insights and those characters' deeds spoke loudly enough to their character and motivation.

If you like historical fiction, especially related to Italy (or specifically, Umbria), enjoy as story with good sense of place and character development, then read The Virgin and the Griffin. Personally, I'm looking forward to Sandra's second book as I still can't believe this was her first endeavor.

Share |

Other Thinks (1)

Sandrac:

Kim, thank you so much for taking the time to review my novel. I really appreciate your criticisms. They are very helpful! I've had some of the same concerns (although I didn't make the Twilight connection - yikes!!!!) But your points will help me with the new novel that I'm working on.

Your assumptions about why I moved the point of view from time to time were absolutely right - I was trying to give some insight into how others felt. But maybe that wasn't necessary; thanks for your faith that I could express their thoughts through my writing!

In terms of Letizia, a few other friends have also said that they really liked her and wanted more. I love your idea of a possible prequel focusing on Letizia. It seems women want stories about strong women because we know that they're out there now and always have been.

I value your opinion, Kim - thanks for sharing your thoughts on V&G!!!

Post a Think

(If you haven't left a think here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your think will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on October 31, 2012 10:51 AM.

The previous post in this blog was Unbroken.

The next post in this blog is Mad Women.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

 Subscribe to This Blog

Recent Non-Travel Thinks

Powered by
Movable Type 3.33
© 2004 - 2014 Kim Riemann