> SlowTrav > Italy > Vacation Rentals > Reviews > Rome

Review 4925: Cross-Pollinate, Casa Alice


Not Recommended
Review by L.H. from US

2bed/2bath apartment near Pantheon, Rome


March, 2011, 4 nights


This was located close to the Pantheon. It was on the fourth floor of a walk-up.

Nearby Amenities

There is a supermarket about one block from the Pantheon. Plenty of restaurants around the Pantheon.

The House/Apartment

The building was in decent shape. The apartment was not.


There was a small balcony overlooking other apartments.

Furnishings/Cleanliness/Living Areas

The furniture was in moderate shape. The apartment was clean but smelled bad. There were enough chairs.


The beds were fine, but we were not provided enough sheets. The bathrooms were a big problem ... toilet seat missing on one toilet and broken shower that sprayed around the second bathroom.

The owner checked us in. We did not see the broken toilet seat until she left; I emailed her immediately and called her the next morning. When I pointed out that we didn't have enough sheets, she said there was nothing she could do because it was a weekend. She sent sheets two days later.


The kitchen was barely usable. Something was wrong with the water pressure and there was no hot water. I did not discover the kitchen faucet/shower faucet problems until the second day, and emailed the owner again as well but did not receive a response.

Problems or Bonuses

We had high hopes for this agency, which my daughter used for booking an apartment in Rome two summers ago. Cross-Pollinate is owned by an American couple who make the claim that "What makes Cross-Pollinate different from other reservation systems is that all of our properties are personally researched, inspected and revisited so we can confidently recommend places we feel reflect the best value." We found this not to be the case.

Here is what we encountered in Casa Alice:

  • Rank smell. Like a sewer.
  • One of the toilet seats was missing.
  • We were not given enough sheets. One guest slept uncomfortably with no sheets on her bed.
  • Water pressure in the kitchen was down to a trickle, and there was no hot water either. I had to haul water in from another room and boil it on the small electric stove in order to wash the breakfast dishes.
  • We were given one set of towels apiece. Now I don't mind, and fully expected, to launder towels on our stay, but since this place has no dryer wouldn't we need two sets each ... one to use while the other is hanging out to dry? It was positively unsanitary.
  • Wall-hook which was supposed to hold the shower head in the back bathroom was broken, which resulted in much water spraying around. Of course, we couldn't clean it up (because of not being provided enough towels) so that room stayed a swampy mess for our visit.

Agency and Representatives (and price)

By day three of our seven night stay and after contacting both the apartment owner and the owner of the Cross-Pollinate agency repeatedly via email, we were weary with feeling like we were camping in this Rome apartment. I contacted the Cross-Pollinate owner again and told him we were leaving the next day (Day 4). I reviewed our problems, at length, and suggested that not only was Casa Alice misrepresented but we were spending most of our vacation contacting, re-contacting, and generally trying to get the attention of anyone who would help us. Not how we wanted to spend vacation in Rome.

Though Cross-Pollinate handled the bookings for this property and took a deposit from my credit to hold it they told us there was nothing they could do since we rented directly from the owner.

Do you recommend this vacation rental to others?

I understood this to be a basic, but clean and serviceable apartment. I cannot recommend either Casa Alice or Cross-Pollinate due to both the condition of this apartment and the response of Cross-Pollinate.

Agency/Owner Response

My apologies for the lengthy response here but it's rare we have negative reviews and I take it quite personally.

When dealing with a large number of people, such as we do, and offering personal recommendations in foreign environments for limited budgets, I have to accept that sometimes people will simply not be happy with their property and won't share our opinion of what is or isn't good value. I've worked with Casa Alice since about 2004 and have never had bad reviews for them. On the contrary - a search will show some very satisfied guests over the years. I also personally visited the property last week after this complaint and overall still find it to be a great deal. There is indeed a smell from one of the bathrooms that comes up from the very old pipes (the building is probably early 1800's), but it goes away as the water is used in the sink. This is a problem that persists throughout Rome and is not limited to this apartment. However, for the price of 160 euro for 4 people, a couple blocks from the Pantheon with TV, wi-fi, A/C and two bedrooms, two bathrooms - I think most people see that it is still worthwhile and are more than willing to show a bit of understanding for this imperfection.

I am sorry these guests did not find everything to their high expectations and had worked with them since their arrival to resolve their issues. The problem, however, was that they clearly were not aware of what our role was, nor what our policy is. At the time of reserving they were presented with an option of a 10 euro insurance policy which would have covered any losses in the event that they wanted to cancel for ANY reason at all. They declined this option and thus accepted our normal cancellation policy - which they had to "click to accept" to complete the booking, and which was also repeated in their confirmation letter. However, when they decided they no longer wanted to stay at Casa Alice they wrote, "I don't known what your refund policy is with dissatisfied clients, but given that we paid her for seven nights and are leaving after four, I would appreciate some consideration for compensation for the nights we are not using. We will be out of here tomorrow by 10:30 a.m."

In defense of ourselves and the owner I'll respond to some of the actual details: the guest arrived on a Saturday and the following day notified us of the broken toilet seat and requested more sheets. Since they had changed from 4 people to 3 people, the owner did not understand that they needed 3 separate beds (thinking two were a couple). Since this was not specified by the guest, a double bed and a single bed as opposed to 3 single beds is what was made up for them. However, the owner uses a cleaning service that does not operate on Sundays, so she was unable to bring them sheets as quickly as they would have liked. Same for the toilet seat. It was fixed, but perhaps in "Roman time", despite our efforts to move things along quickly. I do not want to downplay the discomfort of a broken toilet seat or sleeping in a sleep sack - if they were important to the guest, then they are important to me. However, by no means would I consider those issues to make the apartment "unlivable". A gesture of good faith from the owner to show she was sorry would have been enough, in my opinion - but this is also a culturally delicate matter. Not everyone in the world thinks of problems as being monetarily compensable. Sometimes a bit of patience to work out imperfections is more useful that any attempt to quantify how much it's "worth".

In any case, at the time, these were the only two complaints that were voiced by this guest, and therefore, the only two things we set out to rectify. On day 4 of their 7 night stay they wrote with a series of other minor complaints and said that they would be leaving and would like a refund (and stating as per the quote above that they didn't know what our policy was in such cases). I responded immediately saying that we could attempt to resolve these new issues, and if we could not resolve them, could help negotiate a discount for them, but that if they wanted to leave, after 4 days, we would consider it a voluntary cancellation and as per our policy it would not warrant a refund.

The guest left anyway despite my warning and persisted with asking for a refund from me - without understanding that we are not the owners and do not have the power to offer a refund. Our policy, which they admitted to not knowing, clearly stated what we can and cannot do in the event of complaints, and clearly stated that refunds were under the sole control of the owner. Regardless, we contacted the owner and pushed for a refund anyway, since we sympathized with the guest and in general don't feel good about anyone losing money unnecessarily. In the end, after repeated efforts (even a visit in person to the apartment), the owner felt that it was unfair of them to ask for a refund as she had succeeded in fixing their problems and didn't understand why, if they were so unhappy there, they hadn't made that clear from the beginning even having seen her in person and not mentioning these problems to her directly.

I communicated this to the guests, along with my sympathies and apologies, and felt that I had been professional, responsive, and quick on acting on their behalf. I tried to delicately point out that it is a rarity as an agent in the property rental business to have someone offer assistance with a guest's stay at all. They responded with a threatening letter.

We have very flexible policies (probably the most flexible around for apartment rentals) and make very clear what we can and cannot do - so that both owners and guests know what to expect of us. If people cannot take the time to inform themselves properly of the commitment they are making, there is little we can do about it officially. If guests want even more flexibility and no financial risk, we will assume that risk for them with just a 10 euro insurance surcharge. I really don't see how else we could offer a better service. It is upsetting when we go above and beyond the call of duty to help someone, and our efforts for a quality, personal service, results in being attacked and offended personally.

This review is the opinion of a Slow Travel member and not of slowtrav.com.

Back to Top

Return to Reviews List

Car Rental Hotel Booking Flight Booking Train Tickets Books, Maps, Events
Europe Cell Phones Long Distance Cards Luggage, etc. Travel Insurance Classifieds

* Advertise on Slow Travel | Post your travel questions on the Slow Travel Forums

Copyright © 2000 - 2014 SlowTrav.com, unless noted otherwise. Slow Travel® is a registered trademark. Contact Slow Travel

RSS Feeds - Link to Us - Terms of Use - Privacy Policy - IB Cookie Policy - Currency Converter - Colophon - Sponsors - Become a Member
Home | Forums | Slow Travel? | Europe Trip Planning | Photos | Trip Reports | Search | About Us | Classifieds